Best Wheelbarrow for Horse Manure (Reviews) 2020

Best Wheelbarrow for Horse Manure

The wheelbarrow has been a constant, reliable tool used to move heavy loads of various materials across a range of environments for years. It can be used in construction sites, on the beach, and, most prominently, on a farm or ranch.

If you own horses, you know that their manure can be heavy to move around especially in large quantities. That’s why it’s important to have the ​right wheelbarrow for horse manure in your barn or shed, ready to assist you with the otherwise daunting task of cleaning up horse waste.

We’ve made a list of the five best wheelbarrows for the job​ with reviews included below.

Top 5 Rated Comparison Table

​Image

Wheelbarrow

​Capacity

​Material

​Price

Rubbermaid Commercial Cart

​​1. Rubbermaid Commercial Cart

Editors Choice

​200, 300, and 700 ​lbs

​​High-density polyethylene

Marathon Yard Rover

​300 ​lbs

​Polypropylene plastic

Gorilla Carts Heavy-Duty Poly

​1200 ​lbs

​Poly plastic

Polar Trailer 8449

​400 lbs

​Polyethylene plastic

Best Choice Products

​​330 lbs

​Steel, polyurethane plastic

​Reviews of the Best ​Wheelbarrows for Horse Manure


Rubbermaid Commercial Products Plastic Yard Cart

Rubbermaid makes a lot of convenient, high-quality and durable products and their commercial cart wheelbarrow is a great example of their standards for quality.

This wheelbarrow comes in four different sizes with three capacities and two different wheel types, so you can really customize what kind of equipment you’re getting and what kind of work you’ll be able to handle with it.

This wheelbarrow was designed to be easy to maneuver and dump and is incredibly durable. It won’t chip, rust, leak, peel, or dent with heavy use.


Pros

  • ​This wheelbarrow comes in four different sizes with three different capacities and two different wheel types, giving you plenty of options to choose from
  • Made with smooth, high-density polyethylene plastic
  • Designed to be easy to maneuver and dump
  • Won’t rust, dent, chip, peel, or leak during use
  • The large wheels make navigation simple on any terrain type

Cons

  • ​The handle is a little short for some and results in the rear support being kicked while walking the wheelbarrow



Marathon Yard Rover

The Marathon Yard Rover by Garden Star is focused on offering user-friendly products at a low, budget-friendly cost. This wheelbarrow, as a result, is not only a low-cost option to meet your horse manure needs, but is also simple to use and easy to assemble.

This wheelbarrow has a 300-pound weight capacity and uses two air-filled pneumatic tires to transport your haul easily and efficiently to where it needs to be taken. When empty, it weighs a measly 25 pounds, making it easy to move and store when not in use.


Pros

  • ​Constructed of polypropylene plastic, which is very durable
  • Has a 300-pound weight capacity
  • Uses two air-filled 14.5-inch tires for balance and maneuverability
  • Easy to assemble
  • Lightweight, weighing only 25 pounds while empty

Cons

  • ​​Can be difficult to assemble due to the holes being drilled at incorrect angles, but this may be a quality-control issue that does not seem to ​affect all models



​​​Gorilla Carts Heavy-Duty Poly Yard

Gorilla Carts is known for making high-quality, heavy-duty products to help you get all of your work done as easily and efficiently as possible. The result of this goal is this heavy-duty poly yard dump cart.

This wheelbarrow cart will haul an impressive 1,200 pounds of waste and material in its fully rust-proof tray. It has increased ground clearance and better maneuverability than many other wheelbarrows and carts.

This cart comes with a patented quick-release dump function, which makes unloading much easier on you and streamlines the process.


​Pros

  • ​Comes as either a single unit or in packs of up to four
  • Can pull up to 1,200 pounds of material or waste with ease
  • The tray is completely rust-proof
  • Uses a patented quick-release dump feature for easy unloading
  • Has a reduced assembly time with increased ground clearance and maneuverability

Cons

  • ​​Sometimes can have quality control problems regarding the ease of assembly



Polar Trailer 8449 Heavy-Duty Cub Cart

The Polar Trailer Heavy-Duty Cub Cart is made with a high-impact polyethylene tub, shielded ball bearings, and two rugged, wide-track rubber tires. It can haul 400 pounds worth of material, waste, and horse manure across your yard or farm with ease every time.

This cart only weighs 35 pounds when it’s empty, and it’s a convenient, storage-friendly size for when you’re not using it. The shielded ball bearings help to provide smooth, uninterrupted operation on any kind of terrain, whether it be gravel, sand, mud, or more.


​Pros

  • ​​​Has a load weight capacity of 400 pounds
  • The high-impact, durable polyethylene wheelbarrow weighs only 35 pounds when empty
  • Has shielded ball bearings
  • Uses two 16-inch wide-track rubber tires to operate smoothly on any terrain type
  • The wheelbarrow is easy to assemble and maneuver

Cons

  • ​The tires are air-filled and may leak or burst under enough pressure, so keep that in mind - The manufacturer will send new tires or air tubes if your wheelbarrow is still under warranty



Best Choice Products Dual-Wheel Home Wheelbarrow

The final wheelbarrow on our list is this dual-wheel model from Best Choice Products. It really does live up to the company’s name, too. Made of powder-coated steel, polyurethane, and rubber, this wheelbarrow is made for longevity and with durability in mind.

The thick, padded loop handles double as a stand when you want to store this wheelbarrow in a small space and also make pushing the wheelbarrow much easier and more comfortable.

As an added bonus, you can order expert assembly with this wheelbarrow, so you don’t even have to worry about putting it together.


​Pros

  • ​​​Can be ordered with or without expert assembly, so you have the option of removing the hassle of assembling it yourself
  • Has thick, padded loop handles that double as a stand and make pushing the wheelbarrow comfortable
  • Made of powder-coated steel, polyurethane, and rubber for a durable, rust-proof performance
  • Has 13-inch rubber pneumatic wheels which make navigating rough terrain easy
  • Has a weight capacity of 350 pounds

Cons

  • ​The instructions for this wheelbarrow are a bit unclear and may seem particularly vague for some​


​Horse Manure Wheelbarrows Buying Considerations

While searching for the best wheelbarrow for horse manure, there are three key factors that you should keep in mind. These are the wheel types, capacity or load size, and tray material types and durability.

Wheel Types

One of the important factors to consider when shopping for a new wheelbarrow is the wheels. There are two types of wheels that your wheelbarrow may come with.

Pneumatic Tires

These are small tires that look like those that you’d find on your car, truck, or other vehicles. They come complete with inner tubes and can handle heavy loads.

They’re great for use on soft or loose ground, and the wider the tire is, the more smoothly it will roll over different types of ground including mud, sand, or gravel.

Solid or Flat-Free Tires

They will never go flat, which is a risk that comes with pneumatic tires. Some solid tires are molded from a singular, solid piece of hardened rubber while others look like pneumatic tires. These variations are usually molded with tiny air pockets inside which helps to cushion the weight of the wheelbarrow.

While these tires are typically more durable and can handle heavy loads, they’re also naturally harder and will usually give your wheelbarrow a rougher ride.

Capacity or Load Size

As any horse owner knows, a horse can produce an impressive amount of waste and manure. You may also have realized that your horses will not graze on the grass where their manure sits. Who would? The longer the manure is left in a space, the more it can affect the future grazing habits of your horse or horses.

With these things in mind, it may be obvious that the higher the capacity that your manure wheelbarrow can handle, the more manure you can remove at a time.

Typically, the capacity of a wheelbarrow is measured in cubic feet, but that may not be especially helpful when determining how much manure you can move at one time.

Along with the width and depth, the height of your wheelbarrow should be considered to help in determining just how much manure you can move at one time.

It’s best to opt for higher capacity wheelbarrows, especially when you have multiple animals to clean up after.

Tray Material Types and Durability

There are primarily two material types that you will see when searching for a wheelbarrow with which to move your horse manure. These are plastic and metal. They may be different blends of materials falling into either of these categories and some will use a combination of plastic and metal.

Plastic

Plastic wheelbarrows are sometimes preferred over metal. This is because they are versatile, lightweight, and durable while being easy to clean by simply spraying it out with a hose. They also require very little maintenance overall.

Metal

Alternatively, some people prefer metal wheelbarrows which are usually made of steel or aluminum and have strong, protective coatings. They are typically more durable than plastic, but also tend to be heavier and require more care and maintenance.

The Final Word

The wheelbarrow is a versatile, useful tool that can make almost any large or heavy-duty job easier as far as transportation is concerned. When you need the best wheelbarrow for horse manure, you should absolutely consider one of the choices we’ve reviewed here.